Earlier this evening while out of a run, listening to Terry Real’s latest book US; I heard him quote a poem from Rumi I had never heard before. The quote was “Out beyond ideas of right and wrong, there is a field. I’ll meet you there.” When I got home, I googled the words I had jotted down in my hurried pause to capture the moment, and I found the full poem, entitled A Great Wagon. The middle piece of the poem reads
“Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing, there is a field. I’ll meet you there.
When the soul lies down in that grass,
the world is too full to talk about.
Ideas, language, even the phrase “each other”
doesn’t make any sense.”
Something in these words captured me. They made sense. And yet they contained in them a challenge for many of us, which is to set aside the notion of who is right and who is wrong and instead to find a place to meet together, as equals. In my work with couples I encounter the damaging effects of right and wrong, better and worse, above and below. I see the direct impact of one up versus one down dynamics and power differentials and how these can destroy safe connection and vulnerability faster than anything. John Gottman has long identified contempt as the most destructive of the Four Horsemen, identifying it as sulfuric acid on the relationship.
The longer I have been working with couples, the more convinced I am, that we are all seeking to be seen and heard and valued, the hallmarks of Secure Attachment. Do you see me? Do you hear me? Do I matter to you? Am I of value to you? These are the questions that every heart longs to have answered with a resounding yes!
What many of us get trapped in, is a exhausting quest of who’s wrong here? Who’s fault is this? Who needs to change? Who needs to apologize? We are so desperate to be validated and acknowledged, to know that we have inherent value, that we desperately cling to the false notion of “being right”. But what we discover as we peel back the layers of these quests, we always find the same thing; we find a deep seeded longing to be seen and heard and valued. So why is it so hard to acknowledge someone else’s experience? Why is it painful to validate someone else’s viewpoint? Because we feel a direct threat to our own existence. Because we have been taught to believe that there is a right and a wrong and to always land in right.
What we have not been taught, is that when it comes to intimacy and connection, right and wrong have to dissolve. Instead we have to lean into the discomfort of simply having our own opinion and perspective with no status of right or wrong. Simply standing in our own experience. And somehow this feels threatening. It’s vulnerable to just stand in your own experience and not posture all about your being right. So we fight hard against it. And we cling to being right. And we cling to pointing out all that is wrong. All the while not realizing we are building a strong castle to dwell within, alone… because no one wants to live with someone who is always right and therefore has to accept being always wrong.
Rumi’s poem speaks so eloquently to this noting. There is a field between…. I’ll meet you there. I don’t know that I’ve ever heard a more beautiful metaphor, to encapsulate what we as couples need to do. To leave our walled in towers surrounded by motes and to meet in the field between. This depicts vulnerability in the most visible way. I’ve left my castle walls. You’ve left yours. We’re unprotected here out in this field. But we’re side by side. On neutral ground. And we’re choosing connection over the safety of being right.
A tool we utilize in the Gottman Method directly addresses contempt and defensiveness by teaching all of us to speak about our feelings and our longings and to avoid criticizing our partner. Contempt often comes in the form of “I know more than you do” or “I have evolved more than you have”. The Gottman method teaches us to acknowledge our own flawed ways of being human. None of us are above mistake. None of us are above hurting someone else while trying to protect ourselves. Our relationship connection is in a constant state of fluctuation. To quote Terry Real, PhD and creator of Relationship Life Therapy, “Every relationship is an endless dance of harmony, disharmony and repair”. We will mess up. We will occasionally choose being right over relationship. We will occasionally hurt our partners, which will inevitably create a disconnect or conflict. What Gottmans research has taught us, is that repair is what masters of relationship are so good at. They still mess up and hurt one another. But then they come back and seek repair. They own their part. They apologize. And they acknowledge that they value one another.
This is the real beauty of relationships of all kinds. We have the opportunity to be seen and known. And we get to see and know someone else. This breeds connection and vulnerability. In other words, intimacy.
I long for a world where we would choose to meet in that field. To remove such a strong sense of righteous indignation, to drop the facade of I know everything and have it all together. And instead to embrace the mess that is being human. And to see the stunning beauty that can be found in true connection, where there is no other, but only us.
“Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and right doing, there is a field. I will meet you there”
Chelsea Bliss Ward